larger division support section hearts of iron 4 steam

Most of the time you won't have the same army composition if for no other reason due to production differences. If you want greater flexiblity, go for 20-width divisions, but if you want a smaller number of divivisions to manage, go with 40-width ones. Your choice is essentially an operational question. Twice as large divisions are twice as powerful but you can only bring half of them to bear. In larger fights,note the doubling of stats is negated by double the amount of divisions firing on the larger divisions at any given time. 2 20-divs are equivalent to a single 40 div). Similarly, both 20-divs with 60 attack total can't break through 400 or 40 shields, so each division fires 30 shots each at 10% chance for 3 hits each for 6 total.Īs seen in this small example, there is no meaningful combat difference between a 40-width and 20-width division for the same composition and wdith (i.e. The 40-div's 60 soft attack is not enough to break a single 20-divs's 200 or even 20 shields (this would reqire 2000 and 200 on average respectively), so each shot has a 10% chance to hit for 6 hits. Each division is comprised entirely of infantry battalsions that have 3 soft attack, 20 defense and 2 breakthrough each. Here is the math for a balanced, 2 on 1 fight between 2 20-divs and 1 40-div of equal composition. It is important to remember that in huge battles that it seems damage is not spread evenly across divisions (I suspect each division randomly targets another each combat hour and its possible to have multiple divisions ganging up on 1) and thus units may lose a lot of Org this way. Obviously because of the ludicrous amount of shots needed to reduce the shields given the abysmal low base hit chance, this is not a concern in 1 on 1 division fights. This means that a division with 100 for its defense stat (whether that be Defense or Breakthrough) being shot at 100 times will take 10 hits on average (all hits will be when there are shields left), but taking 1000 shots means that all it's shields will be down (1000 shots at 10% needed to hit 100 times) and that each point over 1000 will have a 4x chance of hitting.

Seems simple, right? Yes, but in order to truly understand damage output I went on the wiki and discovered that each defense point is a 'shield' and that each attack point (a 'shot') has a 10% chance to hit when its target still has shields left and a 40% chance to hit when its target has no shields left. In each round of combat, units 'fire' at each other with their attack stats and do damage based on 'hits'. Divisions have different attack and defense stats as determined by battalion number and type as well as technollogy and doctrine.Ģ. More practically speaking, I actually did some math for you on whether a 40-div and a 20-div are truly equal in combat.įirstly, we have to understand the HOI4 combat system:ġ. Of course, the first part is theoretical I would only have to assume that 20 divisions could take on 1 if you had an equal number of battalions on each side. For example, two 20-width divisions and 1 40-division can theoretically do the same amount of work, but two 20-divisions means I can have one in one place and one in another. a single 20-widther goes in favor of the former.Įither way, I go with 20-width divisions because of greater flexibility. I don't see how, in a 1 on 1 match, a division with twice as many battalions could be equally matched. I don't understand what you mean by 'equally matched'.

Larger division support section hearts of iron 4 steam